I'm starting to get worried about my posture working at my desk. I'm not conscientious enough to make this happen myself though - I just don't remember to keep good posture. I'm looking into buying a simple back/shoulder brace. Here is one that I've found that seems OK: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B005H3NKYI/ref=as_li_ss_tl?ie=UTF8&tag=ucmbread-20&linkCode=as2&camp=1789&creative=390957&creativeASIN=B005H3NKYI
My question is: are there any recommendations for solving this problem? I'm looking for something that, if worn, I can wear without it being noticeable, and comfortable to wear for long periods of time (like an entire work day.) I'm open to other suggestions too - I know very little about ergonomics :)
asked Jan 09 '12 at 19:26
As a physical therapist, I recommend that you go see a physical therapist for a postural evaluation, training in how to set up your work station (including the right chair) so it is ergonomically suitable for YOU, and for teaching you exercises to strengthen your postural muscles, which include more than just your abdominals and core muscles. Each person is different. Each human body is different. I caution you to take blanket advice about this online. In 2-3 sessions with a P.T. you will be very knowledgable on how to correct your posture and prevent this from getting worse. I don't recommend a brace...especially advise against wearing a brace for a prolonged period of time....it might correct your posture while you have it on but it creates muscle disuse atrophy in your postural muscles...and you will be MUCH worse off in the long run as a result.
answered Jan 14 '12 at 16:50
The Alexander Technique was invented for this very reason.
And as LG above said, it's a slow solution to a problem that took you a long time to have.
Google it and find an instructor. You'll notice the difference in two hours. Worked for me!
answered Jan 14 '12 at 09:52
Live with your mother!!!
answered Jan 14 '12 at 13:15
Pilates, Alexander Technique, Yoga, etc. can all be quite helpful. PT sessions can be good, but you must treat PT as a partnership/participatory activity instead of something done to you. I'm sure Bob Anderson's book is good, and I like Pete Egoscue's "Pain Free" books.
You did nail one thing: the critical step is awareness. Moshe Feldenkrais figured this out about 50 years ago; he developed Awareness Through Movement lessons. I love the Feldenkrais ATM classes: each hour-long session plays like a little science project.
I'm also quite fond of Eric Franklin's work and books. Franklin has created some of the best exercises plus imagery anywhere to restore our bodies to a state of fluidity/grace/pain-free. There is a huge linguistic component to healthy posture and movement; Franklin has done the best of modern instructors to address the linguistic component of body/mind work. @FranklinMethod puts out some great tweets on this topic: follow him.
What's the right one? It depends. If you had a friend who you trusted who was an instructor of Body/Mind discipline XYZ, I would recommend doing that. The most important thing is what you bring to the table -- what you're willing to commit to do. And there's no rule you have to do only one body/mind discipline. Find what you love to do, and do it.
Structural Integration is a fantastic thing to do, but it's a serious investment and you shouldn't commit to the 10-session (some schools are 12-session) series unless you're ready. I really like SI, and I really like the individuals who have become SI practitioners. They seem to march to a different drummer than most body/mind workers.
Thomas Myers, who has his own SI school, wrote the fantastic essay "Spatial Medicine" (available here. In that essay, he describes a way of thinking about our health and what role "spatial medicine" plays in it. Some body/mind workers speak in a very "woo woo" fashion, but Myers speaks in a way that everyone -- including the geeks and engineers -- can understand and enjoy.
The poster "Dead Ernest" was dead right: no widget will fix what ails you. What will address your concerns is a comprehensive whole-system approach to your posture and movement: a new mindfulness to bring to your posture and movement. It's not a thing; it's a way to approach everything.
Finally, check out the essay The Great Unwinding by the late Dr. Marvin Solit. I don't agree with everything he says, but many of his words are tremendously satisfying to me. Marvin was a mathematician, an inventor of many cool toys and puzzles, and a body-mind worker. I consider myself quite lucky to have met him before he passed away.
I apologize for the large answer. You have asked a vast question. It looks like a simple question, but it is not. Nature builds in whole systems; profound changes to whole systems must themselves be systematic.
I seem to recall a technique that was along the lines of a pen or stick you wore on/near your abdomen. The idea was that if you slouched, you felt the slouch in your stomach and corrected yourself by pain avoidance. A brace becomes a crutch you can never ditch. Slouching is really a deep abdominal muscle issue.
answered Jan 10 '12 at 16:23
Get a good chair and use your brain. Do self-checks and if you find that you're slouching, leaning or favoring one butt cheek over another, straighten up.
answered Jan 14 '12 at 11:42
A 65-cm stability ball like this one:
instead of a desk chair.
You don't have to do a thing but sit on it.
answered Jan 15 '12 at 11:21
These Posture shirts by Evidence Based Apparel are supported by scientific research and evidence based testing.
What is EBA® Evidence Based Apparel? www.eblife.com
The simple crystalline concept of what EBA does better than anyone in the world is posture. Posture is us. Posture brings alignment, balance, and increased stamina. EBA has established patented, groundbreaking technologies for posture correction apparel that begin a new paradigm in wellness and injury prevention. Over six years of clinical experience and scientific research performed at multiple academic facilities, have shown that variable elastic bands (Neurobands), placed in a specific anatomic location, interact with muscles and the neurobiology to stimulate muscle activity. The research and clinical findings (evidence) validate a measurable therapeutic effect. This puts EBA in a category all on its own. EBA truly is evidence based and has been issued United States Patent Number 7,871,388 title POSTURE IMPROVEMENT DEVICE AND METHOD OF USE. What is EBA® Technology?
EBA® posture improvement devices are built with state of the art materials that feature moisture wicking, anti-microbial, and biocompatible properties that meet the demands of advanced physical activity. EBA technology behind the solutions is based on the basic science principles of balance, form and function. EBA designs form fitting garments with variable tension bands called "Neurobands". Neurobands stimulate muscles and nerves to align the body's joints with each stride of the leg or movement of the hip, back, shoulder, chest and neck; in response the body uses less energy and reduced fatigue means less vulnerability to injury. EBA is anatomic apparel that backed with clinical findings from prestigious medical research institutions. EBA garments offer an alternative to individuals with concerns related to muscular, neurological, and postural strain, or to those who simply seek wellness solutions. The company is committed to understanding the interactions of multiple biological responses in the human body and to integrate them into apparel that is comfortable and attractive.
The EBA posture shirts and S3-4 Spine Stabilization devices deliver posture improvement technology through a simple elegant platform championed by the medical professional, the physical therapist, the strength coach and mothers everywhere. Good posture helps prevent injuries, alleviates back and shoulder pain, maintains flexibility, and boosts athletic performance. The Alignmed EBA Posture Shirt uses biomechanical and proprioceptive technology supported by clinical research to immediately deliver touch tension forces triggering a physiological response improving posture. Improved posture increases alignment, balance and stamina. The key to all EBA gear is to listen to what your body is telling you both while you wear the product and after you take it off. What are Neurobands™?
Neurobands™ are defined as dense, closely packed bundles of fibers positioned in a wavy pattern parallel to the direction of pull. Neurobands can have a variety of flexible and elastomeric properties. The elastomeric properties create duel-directional tension forces until the wavy pattern of fibers straighten out by the pulling force. The Neuroband design imitates collagen fibers contained within muscles, tendons, ligaments and the fascia connective tissues. Additionally, Neurobands are strategically placed within the EBA garments to have a snug fit and to have start and stop anchor points, that are relevant to ligaments and tendons that join one bone to another. In this way Neurobands help to transmit balanced movements from muscle to the bones and joints they are attached to or surrounded by. How does EBA® Technology Fit into Your Life?
Over time, the aspects of modern life and aging can be as hard on the body as the challenges in sport. We are not designed for long periods of static, sedentary work. The body thrives on movement and variety. Mother Nature did not design our bodies for long periods of repetitive motions such as sitting or keyboard use. Work-related musculoskeletal repetitive stress injuries (RSIs) are the fastest growing category of work-related illness. Across North America, half of all workers' compensation claims are due to MSI, the most common being low back pain, carpal tunnel syndrome; shoulder pain, and neck pain. It is estimated that over 50% of all RSIs can be prevented. Most work-related musculoskeletal injuries result through risk factors attributed to awkward postures. These risk factors arise from poorly designed workstations and equipment condition, but the biggest rise is due to the computer terminal and the physical stresses it places on joints, muscles, nerves, tendons, bones, general comfort and health. Especially in the hip area!
We must respect many factors in the way we organize workstations. However, EBA is the first to recognize that the most important ergonomic workstation is the "Bio-ergonomic Workstation™" - Otherwise known as our very own body! This requires a paradigm shift in thought; EBA believes the best a critical ergonomic work tool is an EBA Posture Shirt and EBA G1 Tights™ and Footgear.
EBA garment solutions stimulate muscles to joints balance while simultaneously allowing you to move easier without restriction, to do things more efficiently and less prone to injury. It doesn't matter if you are climbing the corporate ladder, shipping supplies, or sitting at a desk in front of a computer terminal; EBA solutions require only a form fitting garment that can be worn as outer or under clothing.
Never has a work tool offered such an economic benefit. Who are Those Who Care?
EBA clients and customers include world-renowned medical centers, professional sporting teams, soccer moms, and active retirees. We have input from over 20,000 individuals and 1400 physicians who have used and recommended EBA garments. These people represent a varied population that includes major universities, renowned medical clinics, physical therapists, strength coaches, computer users, surgeons, law enforcement, soccer moms, Air Force Academy, active retirees, and professional athletes from the NFL, MLB, NBA, NHL, Pro Tennis, MLS, etc... No one is exempt from the stress and strains of their environment. EBA customers are people who care about body preservation or find that the products are an amazing means to make themselves look good!
Posture is your future, Stand up for health!! Check out our products and find out how you can improve your life with E.B.A. Posture Shirts at www.eblife.com
answered Oct 09 '12 at 11:00
I realize that you're looking for a quick and easy fix to a slow-developing but deep-seated problem, and I fear I don't have a simple device I can suggest. I did, however, find that Pilates exercises---classical Pilates, done in a well-equipped studio, with a well-trained instructor---made surprising differences. I had not realized how posture pervades everything: it's a full-body problem and (alas) requires strengthening the muscles and ligaments that pull our bones into place and learning how to control that. For home use, I can recommend Classical Pilates Series: The Complete Mat Workout Series, a $15 DVD that clearly shows the mat exercises for the Basic, Intermediate, and Advanced levels, but aso includes a "Pre-Basic" set to get up to speed.
By recognizing the problem you've taken an important step. Addressing the problem will, I fear, require more than purchasing a device. (YMMV)
answered Jan 14 '12 at 09:44
As a physician of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation I also agree with Beth M. Her answer is the ideal solution. But if you are not willing and/or able to see a therapist at the very least her later point deserves a paragraph of its own.
You do not want a device to hold you in a better position - unless you simply want to appear to have good posture. Such a thing would further weaken the muscles you want doing the job.
However a device such as Christopher mentions; something that 'reminds' you to employ the muscles you should be using would not do any harm (as long as it is encouraging the right posture, and not causing too much damage as it does so ...which may or may not speak to the idea of living with your Mom).
answered Jan 15 '12 at 03:04