login ask-a-question questions unanswered tags faq

My earbuds keep falling out, and my over the top headphones don't stay on. I would also prefer ones that can handle a fair amount of sweat.

asked Jul 20 '11 at 15:21

oliver's gravatar image

oliver
611


« previous12

I use Skullcandy INK'D earbuds. Tight fit, good sound, $15.

link

answered Aug 02 '11 at 07:10

KB1969's gravatar image

KB1969
1

The correct answer is NONE. Running and music may safely be combined when indoors on a treadmill, or on a dedicated path. Certainly not when running on a road or sidewalk. More and more laws are being enacted to restrict the use of earphones and headphones on and near roads.

This is for a very good reason, one I have personal experience with: 25 years ago a runner wearing earphones was waiting for the light to change at an intersection, then proceeded to run across the wrong side of the intersection. I was just entering the intersection on my motorcycle, having timed the light perfectly, only to suddenly find a runner in front of me.

I hit the brakes and horn and veered to miss the runner, but she kept going, never hearing the huge amount of noise my horn and tires were making. I was unable to avoid slamming into her. I had a very rough landing, was knocked unconscious, and almost slid into oncoming traffic.

When I woke in the hospital, two police officers were standing at the foot of my bed. They asked if I knew what had happened, and I told them everything I could remember. My memory ended a moment before the impact. I didn't remember the collision itself or anything after.

They next told me she was declared dead at the scene. My blood pressure crashed and I passed out for a few moments. When I came to again, they said something that's been burned into my memory ever since: "It was not your fault. The witnesses and the evidence at the scene make it clear you did everything possible to prevent the collision. The earphones she was wearing and the volume setting of her music player combined to make her oblivious to the danger she was in. She was negligent to the point that she essentially committed suicide, and used your motorcycle to do so." They said more after that, but my mind had locked up trying to process that last sentence.

Even now, a quarter of a century later, this memory still wakes me, my heart thumping and my hands shaking.

I don't really care if your use of earphones while running kills you. The Darwin Award needs candidates. But I do care that you may inflict needless trauma on others as you exit the gene pool; loved ones and strangers alike.

Please think beyond your musical pleasure to consider your listening environment.

If you are running well away from traffic, then perhaps one of the other answers may prove useful.

link

answered Aug 02 '11 at 13:18

BobC's gravatar image

BobC
1

@BobC : Well, indeed. The OP wasn't asking about headphones for running outside, just for running in general. I submitted a recommendation, but I personally never use headphones while running outside (only on a treadmill). Sorry for your experience--sounds terrible.

link

answered Aug 02 '11 at 13:23

maria's gravatar image

maria
16

@maria: Glad to hear it!

The vast majority of runners do at least some running on or near roads. So to me, "running in general" means "running near roads".

Anywhere moving vehicles and people mix, collisions are going to happen. Runners are seldom hit from the front, since the eyes often will provide enough warning to avoid a collision. Most runners get hit from the back or side, where the ears are the main warning source. Intentionally reducing ear sensitivity while running anywhere near traffic is literally suicidal.

I'm also a runner (a triathlete), Treadmills and oval tracks hurt my knees, and I tend to trip on trails and sidewalks, so I do much of my own running on roads. I often see other runners wearing headphones, and when I can, I talk to them and tell my story. They remove their headphones 100% of the time, at least until I'm out of sight.

There is no safe way to combine music and traffic with running (or bicycling). Just being a runner or bicyclist on a road is hazardous enough without making it worse by adding music.

The music a road runner hears is often their own requiem.

link

answered Aug 02 '11 at 14:19

BobC's gravatar image

BobC
1

I reviewed the VoxLinc bone conduction headphones earlier this year. They are over-the-ear style, but they don't go inside or over your ear, so they actually stay put rather well.

The headphones are designed for athletes such as joggers and cyclists who do their thing near roads and cars. You can hear the music via the bone conduction technology while still being able to hear your surroundings.

We didn't specifically test for heavy sweat, but the design of these headphones should make the sweat pretty much irrelevant.

link

answered Aug 02 '11 at 17:16

drhigh's gravatar image

drhigh
1

I agree with the cheap/disposable route, sadly. I've had experience with Sennheiser, Etymotic. I find these will keep the earbuds in the ear, but I've had other problems, due to the nature of sweat and motion, namely with the jacks breaking and the connection with the cord and earbuds. Leaving only one ear working. The other issue relates to BobC's story - the more expensive noise blocking headphones are probably not safe.

The Apple ipod earbuds are lower build quality and bad audio quality, but at lower volume they barely block traffic noise. And they seem to have lasted just as long as the more expensive choices, when they have broken, I don't feel bad throwing away $100 headphones. I suggest finding a route that allows running in a park with no intersections.

link

answered Aug 02 '11 at 21:59

wayne's gravatar image

wayne
2184

I want to second the Sony MDR-J10 headphones. I actually think they're a great selection for a "cool tool" in general. I've been using them for well over a decade now and at $8 a pair, I have a set in my car, my office, home, etc. They're incredibly comfortable, WAY more comfortable than ear buds, and they stay in while jogging or running around. I really can't speak highly enough about them. I wish they'd make a pair with an in-line microphone for making calls on an iphone. (Sony does make the DR-J115, but it needs an adapter to work with a 3.5 mm jack).

link

answered Aug 04 '11 at 16:12

jradi72's gravatar image

jradi72
1

Your answer
toggle preview

Follow this question

By Email:

Once you sign in you will be able to subscribe for any updates here

By RSS:

Answers

Answers and Comments

Markdown Basics

  • *italic* or __italic__
  • **bold** or __bold__
  • link:[text](http://url.com/ "title")
  • image?![alt text](/path/img.jpg "title")
  • numbered list: 1. Foo 2. Bar
  • to add a line break simply add two spaces to where you would like the new line to be.
  • basic HTML tags are also supported

Tags:

Asked: Jul 20 '11 at 15:21

Seen: 11,522 times

Last updated: Aug 04 '11 at 16:12

powered by OSQA